Everyone knows a lot of the stock horror tropes so it was very exciting to see Riley Sager put a realistic spin on them with Final Girls. This summer he did it again with The Last Time I Lied and it was even better than the first.
With slashers, ‘crazy motherfucker’ is ultimately the explanation and it’s not very satisfying. TLTIL has 3 teenage girls vanish from a summer camp without a trace leaving behind their lone cabin mate Emma still dealing with it years later. When the camp reopens, Emma starts looking for answers.
No spoilers but I will say that all of your questions get answered. This makes me so happy because I love a good resolution. You don’t always get it in life so I want it in my fiction.
Emma is clearly troubled and stalled in her life and goes to get closure. In the process of looking for new information, Emma finds a lot more than she bargained for. Sager toes the line of making Emma unreliable and keeping us guessing who is the bad guy then and now.
The gradual reveal of everything that happened back then is interspersed with the contemporary events of the novel. I understand why Sager did this because it drove me crazy and I kept reading because I wanted to know what happened. The layers are peeled back in just the right amount to give some of the reveals extra punch.
It’s a perfect summer read and I highly recommend it. It resonates even more because Hubs and I will be going to a lake in the Adirondack mountains in a few weeks. 4.5/5